Toby Wagstaff is a writer, editor, and script consultant who has worked closely with many writers, producers, and directors over the years. While his main goal as a consultant is to ensure that each client’s unique voice is expressed in its clearest and most authentic form, working on his own original screenplays pushes Wagstaff to explore deeper parts of himself. Creating original stories and characters requires a tricky alchemy between stretching one’s imagination outward towards new ideas and experiences, and looking inward to find something enduring and personal that wants to be expressed.
Wagstaff transitioned from literary management to full-time screenwriting in 2008 after optioning his first spec script, the high-concept action sci-fi movie Arena, to Summit Entertainment. While the story – a group of soldiers is mysteriously thrust into a shifting landscape and forced into combat for reasons they don’t understand – is propelled by vivid world-building and dynamic action set-pieces, Wagstaff always felt that it had to be anchored by relatable characters and meaningful relationships. At its core, the script is an exploration of what it means to be a soldier: why choose that life in the first place; what makes you keep fighting when you’re not sure you believe in the cause; how do you keep hold of the idea of yourself as a person rather than just being the tool of your superiors; how far do you block out your own instincts to follow orders before you finally refuse them? An intriguing hook and fantastical setting may help grab an audience’s attention, but they will only remain engaged as long as they see something they recognize in the characters, their struggles, and their eventual growth.
As Toby Wagstaff’s career broadened, he signed as a client with Endeavor/WME, and later Verve TLA. His next original spec script was Suck, a quirky vampire comedy-drama. While again employing a fantasy/sci-fi hook, this is a lighter, quirkier story which assumes a much more intimate focus on its characters. Toby uses the vampire metaphor to explore how we navigate relationships and questions of identity in our 20’s – when you can’t see your own reflection in the mirror, how do you figure out how you really are? When you’re still trying to define yourself with reference to your parents, friends, and lovers, what does it mean to feed off them to survive? How do you walk the line of using other people for support without taking a damaging toll on them, without being a parasite?
In a later feature screenplay, The Day I Die, which was optioned by Millennium Films, Wagstaff stepped away from fantasy and the supernatural entirely with a grounded, contemporary thriller even more directly focused on the theme of identity. When the protagonist falls victim to an extreme version of identity theft, he is forced to watch his life being stolen right in front of him. As events spiral out of control, he finds himself simultaneously appalled at what his “fake self” is doing, but also awakened to the fact that his “real self” hasn’t been doing enough with his life. It takes a series of violently escalating crises to force him to step up and be the kind of person he always wished he could be.
Over the course of nearly two decades in the film business, Toby Wagstaff‘s experience has shown him that the questions of identity faced by a writer in Hollywood are often versions of the same questions and choices his characters face. Just as the soldiers in Arena are caught between trying to hold onto their individuality while succeeding in a rigid, powerful, and intimidating system, so the commercial screenwriter has to try and find a way to hold onto their voice while appealing to executives, filmmakers, and ultimately the audience. How do you find a way to sell without selling out? Ultimately, what all of these stakeholders are looking for are original, authentic voices. You might find yourself using your voice to say many things in this business, and often using it to speak for others, but never lose sight of the fact that the voice itself remains yours.
Vents MagaZine Music and Entertainment Magazine